At The Ultimate Diet, we feel that it is important to know what is in the
food you are giving to your pet. We also think you should know why those
ingredients are present.
For the most part, large commercial manufacturers feel exactly the opposite. Though their labels appear simple and straight forward, the companies use phrases that mislead you into thinking that something is either present when it is not, or more nutritional and natural than in fact it is.
As an example, Poultry By-Product Meal, an ingredient found in many brands of
dog food, sounds like a healthy combination of poultry meat: a bit from the
breast, some meat from the wing, a little from the drumstick.
However, according to The Association of American Feed Control Officials,
an independent group that issues guidelines approved by the Food and Drug
Administration, Poultry By-Product Meal "must consist of non-rendered clean
parts of carcasses of slaughtered poultry such as heads, feet, viscera, free
from fecal content and foreign matter except in such trace amounts as might
occur unavoidably in good factory practice." Doesn't sound all that appealing,
does it? (Incidentally, AAFCO does not provide definitions of "trace amounts"
or "good factory practice.")
In addition to the label not really telling you what is in the can or bag, the
order which the ingredients are listed can also be misleading.
Ingredients are listed in descending order of weight (heaviest first) under
standards established by the Center for Veterinary Medicine for the FDA.
Though on the surface this may seem logical, it becomes problematic when
looked at more closely.
For instance, if one were to take an empty dog food can and stuff chicken feathers
into it until it is three quarters full, and then fill the remainder with chicken
meat, clearly the meat would weigh more than the feathers. According to standard
label practices, the chicken would be listed first and the feathers second, even
though the feathers occupy 75% of the "food." Of course, you would never see
"feathers" listed on the ingredients of a can of dog food. If our hypothetical can
of dog "food" were actually available in your grocery store the ingredient list
would contain only one item: Chicken By-Product Meal.
Concerned pet owners will also want to be familiar with another practice common
to pet food ingredient lists: Splitting. Splitting is simply the separating of
like ingredients to mislead you into thinking there is less of something in a
particular food than there is.
For example, Pedigree Puppy and Pedigree Puppy with Lamb list their first
four ingredients as Rice, Ground Corn, Chicken By-Product Meal, Corn
Gluten Meal. By splitting the Corn into two different categories, the
manufacturer is able to move the ingredient further down the list.
However, if you were to add the total amount of corn together, it becomes
highly likely that it would move up the ingredient list. How much higher
up the list? In this case, corn is already the second ingredient. Is it
possible that corn would then be the first ingredient and not the second?
If this is indeed the case, you, as a consumer, have been lead to believe
that this product contains more rice than corn, which, given this scenario
is not absolutely the case.
Finally, it's important to keep in mind the purpose of the ingredients. The food
in the two Pedigree foods mentioned above have rice and corn as the first two
ingredients. You may be asking "What's wrong with rice and corn?" Nothing is
wrong with corn and rice. Unless you're a natural carnivore, which both cats
and dogs are. The digestive systems of our companion animals are geared
towards flesh foods; their primary source of protein (which would be the first
ingredients on the can) should not come from grains and vegetables.
|